Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
6:21AM Wednesday 07 January, 2009
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Ashley Robinson Ashley Robinson is the master of self-deprecation. He reckons he has two sorts of luck – bad luck and no luck. As a lifetime resident of the Coast, this former publican has plenty of nostalgic memories to share.

Why Mark's wrong on Harry

August 6 | Ashley Robinson

A few months ago we had my wife’s 10-year-old great nephew staying with us for a week or so.

One night I came home from work and he is sitting in my chair watching television and all I heard from the speakers was: “It is my aim to spread AIDS throughout the world and I won’t stop until I do”.

Horrified, I went into the room to find out what he was watching and it was South Park, which to the uninitiated is a darker comedy cartoon version of The Simpsons.

Old mate was laughing away until I burst into the room and asked him did his father usually let him watch crap like that which he replied no, so I told him to turn it off.

After I took a breath and tried to recover from what I had exposed this child to while in my care, I decided to sit down and explain to him why that was so wrong what the character on the screen was saying.

But old mate was way ahead of me and he actually sat me down and explained to me that the AIDS that the guy was talking about was actually a community group doing good things that unfortunately picked the wrong four letters of the alphabet to call their group.

The young bloke completely understood what the writers of the bizarre show was on about, which calmed me considerably – not enough to let him watch it again but at least I had some comfort that he understood what was going on.

Now of course I am referring to columnist Mark Furler’s comments about Harry Potter and the influence it may have on young people.

I have a high regard for Mark and his opinion on many things but I find this particular opinion hard to agree with.

I personally think that most children understand what is fact and what is fiction and as per my comments above they really can surprise adults on what they can grasp.

I find it hard to believe that all of a sudden kids are going to be attracted to the occult by watching Harry Potter.

A recent study in England on why their youth were some of the worst behaved in the world revealed that kids were left far too much to their own devices, too much touchy, feely attitudes to organized activities rather than good old fashioned discipline.

I didn’t see any mention of Harry influencing their poor behaviour.

Now take me for instance and what I used to watch on the box when I was a kid.

The Beagle Boys were favourites of mine in the Donald Duck Show. Three brothers quite fat, unshaven with masks on in prison outfits continually robbing people and banks. Now apart from the fat and unshaven part I didn’t and haven’t gone around robbing banks.

The Coyote was another, I always hoped he would catch the road runner but did I go around with an Acme explosives kit blowing up everything in sight.

Of course the Three Stooges had a huge impact on me as a kid.

I tried to model myself on Curly and I think I have been quite successful in the looks department but I can’t remember grabbing anyone with a pair of pliers, although when I think about it Curly was usually the recipient, which may explain a few things.

Now on the darker side, the Munsters, The Adams Family or Bewitched were about the only thing from my day that could be compared to Harry Potter.

In the Munsters, Grandpa was usually blowing things up but I knew it was a comedy. The only damage the Adams Family did to me was I had a distinct resemblance to Pugsley, which my brother frequently pointed out.

As for Bewitched, it actually helped me as it gave me a healthy fear, and respect of mother-in-laws which became handy later in life.

So I guess as long as parents balance their children’s lives, explain to them what is right and wrong, I can’t see how Harry Potter is going to be any harm.

I would be more worried about my great nephew watching Question Time on the ABC, the politicians’ behaviour really could be damaging.

Recent Comments

on 6 August, 2007 at 1:23 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
As an old footballer with a broken nose, I didn't expect you to be able to see straight on this issue, Ashley and you've proven me right.
on 6 August, 2007 at 1:54 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Mathew, I don't know what my broken nose has to do with missing the point but maybe you can enlighten me, but thanks for reading the column anyway.
on 6 August, 2007 at 6:19 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Why Ashley's wrong on Mark being wrong on Harry.

I must caveat my reply by firstly saying that I agree with Ashley re parental guidance trumping near most influences on our children and negating much harm. Also I agree regarding the point (with many examples) that so many TV shows were not being mimicked necessarily by ourselves when we were young and neither by todays youth necessarily directly....but here comes the big but.....do you think that you can measure all the affects of these influences on the development and guidance of an individual?

Can you measure all the subtle lies and cohersive voices that talk to the young minds that partake in the reading of or viewing of the evil elements that are laced throughout the Harry Potter series?

I read the first few books and found the adventure great and some of the virtues of friendship and courage for example came through loud and fantastic. Well written stories. But the dark side was there, which I chose to downplay in my own appreciation, strongly wanting to justify all the strong points of the books.

But as the series went on, the dark side became more overt, but I was somewhat desensitised and able to still justify that the books were still ok in the balance, accounting those other virtues.

But then I realised it was a dupe. A big fat evil dupe. Like most of evil, it comes draped in a beautiful outfit, laced in sugar n cream sauce etc.

I saw that the books were a perfect vehicle to speak at full volume the voice of witchcraft and saucery. To cloak a manual, nearly a treatise on the subject, to permeate the innocent young minds of the masses.

How many million copies sold? It is to the undiscerning that their children will be allowed to soak in the black sauce of evil that permeates the Harry Potter series.

For the family that has Christ as its head, the evil will not have anywhere as near as strong penetrating influence, for those without Christ's protection the evil can really get a foothold and cause significant destruction to enter that life.

Ashley, as emphatically as you have made your statement about Mark being wrong, I am making mine about yours being wrong.

Thanks for the opportunity.
on 6 August, 2007 at 9:48 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Ashley couldn't agree with you more. I grew up in a similar era to you with the Munsters, Addams Family, Bewitched, Three Stooges, Popeye etc and I seem to have turned out OK I haven't gone bald yet so you are one up on me! lol haha
on 8 August, 2007 at 9:39 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Firstly, Steve from Buderim, we both agree to disagree which is why this forum is a great idea, but I must say it was a well balanced response, thanks for you comments. Secondly, Go Girl, we seem to agree on the main points but since that photo was taken I have grown "some" hair. Thanks for reading. regards Ashley
on 17 September, 2007 at 3:05 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Aha, finally someone who see my point of view. I've studyed Marks editorial in my year 11 english class and my teacher agrees with his opinion 100%. I however dont. I think hes completely wrong and i think that if reading these books makes us evil then bring it on!!!

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive