Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
11:57PM Wednesday 07 January, 2009
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Bill Hoffman Whether taking on developers hell-bent on destroying the Coast’s natural appeal or a Prime Minister indifferent to the plight of the poor, Bill Hoffman has never been one to mince his words. Bill’s been a journalist for 32 years, 29 of those on the Coast. Love him or hate him, he'll get you blogging.

The gall of it: Howard's tribute to dead troopers

November 14 | Bill Hoffman

It takes a special kind of gall, of a type only a politician has the capacity to muster.

But there was John Winston Howard on Sunday, his head bowed in reverential remembrance of those of whom he and others like him had required the “ultimate sacrifice”.

Wars are never started by soldiers, something our esteemed prime minister failed to mention in his tribute to our most recent dead.

Instead he concocted a set of words that not only failed to acknowledge his contribution to the demise of young Australians in Iraq and Afghanistan, but managed to suggest that democracy somehow required their lives.

Speaking at an Australian War Memorial Remembrance Day ceremony in Canberra, Mr Howard said the deaths in Afghanistan of Trooper David Pearce and Sergeant Matthew Locke were “a sad reminder of the ageless nature of sacrifice”.

“That both of these deaths should have occurred at the time of an election campaign that celebrates, in a sense, the great democracy not only here but around the world, that they and others who’ve fallen in battle have died for,” he said. “(Their deaths have) reminded us in a real way of the nature of sacrifice in war.”

Was it a measure of respect for those lives or a measure of our national gullibility that Mr Howard was not driven out of that gathering?

Because there stood a man who has been so wilfully dismissive of the lessons of past wars that he marched us into another without any real thought for where the bombs would fall or whom the bullets would seek out.

Interest rate rises, something over which despite his sly promises he has no control, increasingly loom as the sword on which his government will perish.

But it is his role in the anarchy in Iraq and the increasingly bloody conflict in Afghanistan by which history, at least, will hold Howard to account.

As Britain begins to wake up to the fact that as many as one in three of the “sacrifices” its soldiers have made in Iraq was a consequence of equipment failure or blunders caused by poor preparedness, the gap between reality and rhetoric is beginning, there at least, to be exposed.

But here in Australia, now just two weeks out from an election, Mr Howard has been able to get away with sullying with his words an event that should be out of bounds to men of his ilk.

Old soldiers never speak with such vanity. They know the real nature of “sacrifice”, and the futile, senseless ways politicians require men to die.

They know it is politicians who commit nations to war and lure young men into battle.

A drive through the valley of despair

I drove up through the Mary Valley on the weekend, past the signs and their desperate pleas, and was reminded again of the “sacrifice” politicians expect others to make in the name of the greater good.

A dam is needed on the Mary River at Traveston for no other reason than to feed the profit motive of a small group of property developers.

This state government has no plan for Queensland beyond those of the special interests it serves.

One sign spoke of dignity lost. There is precious little afforded – at great cost – by the Orwellian community consultation concocted by this state government, presumably to salve its own conscious.

It can consult all it likes. Anna Bligh would earn some respect, even from those she grinds into the footprint of her greater good, if she just admitted the obvious. Water is being re-valued as a commodity. It is no longer a gift of God nor is it any longer a part of the natural world.

First it will become a liability suffered by the state before being traded to some private equity fund where it will become another ever-increasing component of the cost of living. Add it to the index.

I’m not buying the housing sweetener

John Howard’s desperate last bid for re-election includes a supposed housing affordability sweetener.

Just how boosting property as an attractive investment option can help reduce its cost to home buyers is beyond my limited fiscal awareness.

The proposals relating to tax exemption for parental contribution to offspring bliss seem to do little more than shift cashed-up baby boomers from negative gearing to early deliverance of inheritance while maintaining demand pressure on a sector which could do without it if affordability was truly the objective.

The future grandkids would probably have preferred any tax incentives to be directed at developing sustainable technologies but I guess it is this election – not the one in 2025 – that is shaping policy.

Recent Comments

on 14 November, 2007 at 8:57 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
What got my attention on your paper was mention of the proposed dam on the Mary River & wishing to make my comment on the news here, I joined your list of regular readers.

High Rise property developers no doubt are not happy with being locked out of copying the disastrous Gold Coast Dune bumps where the beach front is shadowed by numerous high rise. Now the Brisbane river has disappointed them in not producing enough tap water they want to tap into the Mary where the rainfall is still in abundance.

I have read that the industrial development of Brisbane has produced that much smog that it has pushed the rain clouds that once fell on the Toowoomba Ranges further north, thus adding to the dilemma of too little rain to fill the Brisbane River’s Dams.

Another explanation is the surface evaporation and the leakage from unsuitable bottom of the dam exasperates the situation. There was an alternative to this vast lake and that was to build five [5] weirs on the tributaries of the Brisbane River, where the bottom of these rivers had proven over time that they were not sieves and the water loss would be minimal as well as holding a combination of water larger than what the Largest of these dams holds.
on 14 November, 2007 at 3:16 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Interesting, Bill Hoffman's take on "The Valley of Despair" where he rolls over,belly up,and meekly accepts the transparent machinations of this reactionary bumbling Labor Government.

Unfortunately this seems to be the modus operandi of the Fourth Esatate these days. In the past, noting that there is a neutered parliamentary opposition, it would take on the role of public defender ,and savagely attack the stupid,inept,unjust,immoral antics of such a duplicitous government with persistent and unrelenting vigour.

But not today.The 4th.estate has joined the parliamentary opposition in its inability to lay a glove on Labor. Suspicion is that this attitude is intentional.and that it pays not to rock the boat,but,who knows?

As a result,ever increasing despair has driven senior public servants and members ot the public to suicide.Marriages and families to break up.Loved ones to be slaughtered in our health and emergency systems.

Lifestyles and life's dreams shattered. Numbers are thousands not hundreds. Yet all we get is small squeeks from this once proud profession.

One wonders why this Government's obsession with acquiring Service assets and selling them to the highest greedy bidder is becoming increasingly frantic.?

Maybe a good start would be to name and investigate the finances of all private companies owned 50% or more by the by the State Government.

One senses more than we know,that maybe,just maybe, the chickens are coming home to roost for this Government. Just how solvent are they?

But with today's pushover media it looks as if we shall have to wait until the "Enola Gay" arrives.
Sad isn't it?
on 20 November, 2007 at 1:23 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Bill re the gall of any pollies using Remembrance day, ANZAC day etc. I was absolutely disgusted and appalled at the Liberal Lord Mayors recent comments that Labor Party members or supporters had no right to be a part of the ceremonies due to the ALP’s objection to the Vietnam War.

Up until now I thought he was a can-do type Mayor achieving things, against the odds for Brisbane.
Now his parents, both of which had successful Federal Government careers representing the Liberal Party, have certainly raised a closed minded Conservative.

There are Vietnam Veterans who are members of probably each of the political parties. In hindsight I think most people acknowledge that the Vietnam War (like Iraq), was a terrible mistake and blunder that needlessly cost far too many human lives. Also the Billions could have been spent far more productively.

Realising that George W cannot be re-elected, I feel the US of A will soon be talking genuine exit strategy. Meanwhile John Winston Howard and (insert smirk here) Peter Costello continue to say, “No exit strategy needed, we are there for the duration.” ie till Hell freezes over.

The Falklands war proved to the world that right wing conservative leaders are only too happy to send troops into conflict, if it assists their Political Careers.
The phenomenon continues.

Andrew Muldoon
Buddina

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive