Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
9:21AM Thursday 20 November, 2008 Sunshine Coast weather Late thunder min 21° - max 29°
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Bill Hoffman Whether taking on developers hell-bent on destroying the Coast’s natural appeal or a Prime Minister indifferent to the plight of the poor, Bill Hoffman has never been one to mince his words. Bill’s been a journalist for 32 years, 29 of those on the Coast. Love him or hate him, he'll get you blogging.

Pipe dreams trashing lives

August 27 | Bill Hoffman

The anger has spread from the Mary Valley and now embraces the entire Sunshine Coast.

The reality of what some may have been seen at first as a problem to the north of us is now well and truly impacting across the entire region.

A swathe of easement, 40 metres wide, is being cleared to accommodate a 1.2 metre diameter pipe to carry our water at great expense to provide water security elsewhere.

As a plan for the future, it is an expensive folly. Coupled with the proposed construction of the Traveston Crossing dam we are witnessing the trashing of property rights and lives to create an entity that will eventually be fully privatised and already bears the mark of that fate.

Whoever eventually gets control of south-east Queensland’s water supply will not be sharing any dividend with those whose rights were trashed in the process.

People like Jo Moore at Peachester and Rodger Shepherd at Landsborough who have been introduced to readers of this publication in recent days, tell stories of how they have been treated that defy the spin of the liaison officers and communication companies that now litter the ground from Glasshouse to Traveston.

The government hides behind the convoluted structure it has set up to manage water into the future.

No elected official answers the distress of a single mother trying to get on with her life who can’t sell a property that has been turned into a moonscape.

No elected official explains to a 65-year-old retiree why a mountain of dirt at his back door hasn’t been shifted.

That responsibility falls to LinkWater, the trading name for the Queensland Bulk Water Transport Authority, which is just one of potentially 15 separate companies, the creation of which will somehow make water supply and distribution more secure and simpler than leaving it in the hands of local authorities to manage their own affairs.

In the hierarchy of the South East Queensland Water Grid, LinkWater sits below the Queensland Bulk Water Supply Authority, in charge of catchments, dams and treatment and the Manufactured Water Entity which controls purified recycled water and desalinated water.

No doubt sexy names for the pair of them are being worked out as the bulldozers - employed by construction companies Northern Network Alliance with its catchy “innovative and sustainable water solutions” slogan - plough through people’s garden beds.

After LinkWater in our wonderful new Waterworld comes the water grid manager who will oversee the operation of the water grid and who will be responsible for the purchase of water from those above it and the sale to those below.

A distribution entity – that’s where local authorities come in – is responsible for water reticulation and waste water management. Then potentially 10 retailers will get to set a price and face the public.

This structure and dinosaur-like approach to the issues of sustainability that will, with climate change, increasingly confront us gives both government and bureaucracy the illusion that the unsustainable practices of the past can be continued indefinitely.

And it’s not just water. The rolling out of Powerlink’s energy grid is not only trampling all over the property rights of individuals and creating more visual offence than any graffiti artist could ever aspire to, but it is also tying us to the non-renewable supply of coal-fired power stations.

A group of Eumundi and Eerwah Vale residents yesterday took their vision for a more decentralised approach to power supply and delivery to Mines and Energy Minister Geoff Smith. It is unlikely they received a sympathetic ear.

His answer to a question I put recently about alternatives to coal-fired power made it abundantly clear that decentralisation of power supply is not an option.

This was part of Mr Smith’s response: “Make no mistake, coal will still continue to play a role in the global electricity mix. Our key challenge is to use it in a responsible and environmentally sustainable way.

"That’s why we’re injecting $10 million into an oxy-fuel project being developed by CS Energy near Biloela in Central Queensland.

"The project involves using a conventional power station and burning the coal in pure oxygen – which makes it easier to capture the carbon dioxide. It’s expected to demonstrate that coal-fired power stations can be retro-fitted with this technology to achieve deep cuts to carbon emissions. That’s important in a state with more than 32 billion tonnes of high-quality, low-cost, easily-accessible, black coal.

"It’s being funded by the Rudd Labor Government, the Bligh Government through CS Energy, and our partners - the Australian Coal Association’s Coal 21 Fund, Xstrata, Schlumberger, the Japanese Government and Japanese participants – JPower, Mitsui & Co. and IHI Corporation."

Stand aside, they’re coming through.

Recent Comments

on 27 August, 2008 at 10:04 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Disgusting behaviour by all involved. Is there some sort of spell put on politicians and corporate business people? something that makes them stupid? Where is the common sense? How environmentally friendly is it to cut a swathe of land up and destroy all in the path of this venture?

Apparently the limited coal supplies we have are going to come under that same spell and become limitless and environmentally friendly. why is the money not put towards installing solar panels on top of every building in the state to provide limitless free power to all? Why not put the money towards water tanks to catch rain water that falls and is washed out to sea?

Ahh the city is too dirty and the water is undrinkable, ah and you cant charge someone for something they get for free. i get it now, lets pretend that we are going to do something that seems to be sustainable and it makes it look like we care about the future and the environment not to mention the public, but really lets just make as much money as we can now cause when there are water and power shortages we can buy water and provide power from........ uummm. Where people?
on 28 August, 2008 at 3:24 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Posted on behalf of Diet Simon, of Tewantin:

The minister's name is Geoff Wilson, not Smith. Otherwise, Bill, great stuff as usual.

I can add to what happened at the meeting between Wilson and the Eervah Vale folks from an interview I did for Noosa Community Radio with Graham Smith, their coordinator. In a nutshell, this is what Graham told me:

The minister is taking them seriously as a group. He has agreed to stay in touch with them, including with more meetings. He'll look at any commercially viable, alternative projects they put up to him. He'll tell Powerlink to give them more information. The human pain was hardly mentioned because the main focus of the meeting was on a cleaner energy future.

Seems to me like putting the cart before the horse to ask a group of ordinary folk to work out "commercially viable" alternatives. That's the government's job, which can spend our tax dollars to do that. What sort of resources, by comparison, can private people draw on to do that sort of thing? I think Wilson is just buying time, making friendly noises while not budging an inch, knowing full well such a challenge has to be beyond ordinary people's capabilities.

What a bunch of tyrants!

on 29 August, 2008 at 5:01 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Hey guys - never underestimate the talent that is out there. There is a will in the community to change, the council is looking for projects that will start turning their sustainability vision into reality and this isn't just a bunch of community individuals with all the gear and no idea.

No doubt Wilson is playing politics, fully expecting the community to fail and then continue with business as usual destroying peoples lives, properties and increasing greenhouse pollution exponentially until the miracle of clean coal appears at the end of the rainbow, brought into being by the clean coal fairy. This is the only way the coal lobby and the government's advisors (Powerlink included) can think - large inefficient centralised power generation. Is there any wonder they are incapable of thinking about alternatives and other solutions.

Women didn't get the vote because the politicians thought it would be a good idea, did the Berlin wall fall through East Germany's politicians saying, let's think outside the square, did the Bridges development get canned because the government said oh no we've made a mistake. No - all these things happened because people got off their backsides and did something out of the ordinary - they fought and argued and reasoned for what they believed in. It's no different here.

Vive the Energy Revolution - coming to a suburb near you soon!

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive