Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
3:14PM Wednesday 07 January, 2009
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Bill Hoffman Whether taking on developers hell-bent on destroying the Coast’s natural appeal or a Prime Minister indifferent to the plight of the poor, Bill Hoffman has never been one to mince his words. Bill’s been a journalist for 32 years, 29 of those on the Coast. Love him or hate him, he'll get you blogging.

Why we have to say sorry

January 30 | Bill Hoffman

The form of prime minister Kevin Rudd’s apology to Aborigines for past injustices is yet to be known, but any suggestion that it is not long overdue is a continuation of the denial of historical fact.

New Coalition leader Brendan Nelson does him self no credit to suggest that the Rudd government has more pressing priorities. Eleven years of Coalition government found no time to address a wrong that should have been acknowledged a long time ago.

Nor should an apology be purely about the past.

Government treatment of Australia’s indigenous people since first settlement has informed an undercurrent of racism that exists to this day.

Saying sorry is not just about what happened 200 years ago, 100 years ago or even 50 years ago.

Suggestions to the contrary deny the undercurrent that shuts this nation off from the rich cultural heritage aboriginal Australia has to offer.

A formal apology to indigenous Australians should also be personal.

It affords an opportunity for every one of us to examine our own actions and attitudes and to draw a line under behaviours that have no place in an educated, intelligent society.

To its credit, the Queensland government always acknowledges the traditional owners of the land when and where ever it conducts its business. At dinner functions this often includes the performance of a welcoming dance by local aborigines.

On many occasions I have witnessed appalling displays of rudeness and outright contempt by members of our business community whose sneers and disparaging comments point to a sickness of spirit that desperately needs addressing.

Look around on the Sunshine Coast and everywhere are place names which speak to our links to a people whose history stretches back to before the birth of Christianity.

Yet there is scant evidence in our communities of the people who fished the waters and carefully harvested the bounty of a paradise, once rich in its biodiversity but now sacrificed to the singular pursuit of another subdivision opportunity.

It is high time we understood and acknowledged what happened to these first Australians.

Mr Rudd is only partly right when he says that a formal apology will “bridge the gap” with non-indigenous Australians. While a government apology is long overdue, it will remain essentially meaningless until all Australians look beyond their individual ignorance, preconceptions and prejudices and embrace the real history of the land in which we live.

And while that may take several generations to fully accomplish and will require some serious re-thinking of the history taught in our schools, “Sorry” is as good a place as any to start.

The issue of compensation for those still suffering the impacts of their forced separation from parents and extended families is already being addressed through the courts.

The landmark Bringing Them Home report recommended that compensation be paid. The South Australian Supreme Court did just that last year, awarding more than half a million dollars to a 55-year-old who never recovered from his forced removal from his family.

It is best that these matters be resolved before the courts rather than in some sort of blanket cash settlement by the government. That process, while painful to each individual involved, is essential to developing a national understanding of the damage wrought.

Compensation may be difficult for many white Australians to accept but all Australians have a right to the courts as a vehicle to address injustice.

What we should all have the capacity to understand though, is that there is no more painful loss than the loss of a child or a parent.

Aborigines have only been counted as part of our population for the past 40 years yet have fought in all areas of conflict in which Australia has been involved since nationhood.

They are Australia’s original inhabitants, their history is the early story of this nation. Until that is properly acknowledged and the wrongs of the past 200 years fully addressed, we will remain a country divided and weaker for that fundamental failure.

Recent Comments

on 30 January, 2008 at 11:06 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
On Radio National this week I listened to an Indigenous woman recount the story of her mother's abduction from their camp some 6 or 7 decades ago. She described how a large group of government men on horses came to their remote camp when all the men were away hunting and rounded everyone up with whips like livestock.

No-one spoke their language so there was no explanation. The children were separated out and taken away, never to see their families again.

How can you hear that and *not* think that it is something that the government of this country should apologise for?

And how about the Queensland Government's abyssmal dealing with the $Ms of wages stolen by the government in decades past, from people who are still alive? Beattie offered them a paltry $3000 go-away money...Anna Bligh has to resolve this, or there will be no moving on in Queensland.
on 30 January, 2008 at 1:18 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
What a great article and very relevant considering all this fuss about what Australia Day means to us. Does anyone ask an indigenous person this question. I do wonder however if the "Education Revolution" Mr Rudd talks about includes the 'REAL' history of this country. I suppose 'sorry' is a start.
on 30 January, 2008 at 2:21 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
I feel very much for aboriginal people affected by white settlement in this country. However there has been numerous projects, ideas, court decisions ets concerning the plight of aboriginies. When is it going to end? Every time one decision is made another claim, counter claim so forth and so on appears. There was land rights which was a biggee and is still going on, A.T.S.I.C was also going to fix things look what happened there. How many more times must we all endure prolonged claims against the Aust. Taxpayer, the legal fraternity has a field day. I just wish someone would come up with something so that all Australians can get on with their lives. I dont feel that sorry is ever going to be enough.
on 30 January, 2008 at 5:58 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
I met a man in Alice Springs. A dignified man. A Proud man. A Happy man. A Wise man. A passionate man. He tells me he and thousands like him thank their various Gods that they were lucky enough to be rescued (Stolen?) from a life of destitution and squalor and instead received an education and succour from the Missions of that time. As a result,he has been employed all his life. He has and will continue to love, provide for and protect his family. He is now passionately involved in assisting Redfern youngsters out of the miasma grandly bestowed on them by the Gough Whitlam era of mismanagement.

He, and others of his ilk, distrust the comments of Aboriginals safely enjoying overpaid Govt. Quango positions. He is bemused by the pontifications of urban middle class idealists as espoused in the Hoffman article. He believes this latest Labor Stunt is consistent with their efforts in the past. Following the flush of good feelings, all will soon be forgotten. Nothing will change. Labor will fix it as it always has........just throw more money at it. There you go, done and dusted.

In the meantime he and his kind will quietly get on with it and continue to silently say thank you.
on 31 January, 2008 at 10:46 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
"SORRY!" The statement is a cop-out waste of time. Too much talk and not enough action, but that is to be expected from our parlimentarians. What has happened in the past has been done and cannot be changed. The nation must move ahead as a whole. I feel both aboriginal leaders and government leaders are both waste time and energy on this issue.!!!

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive