Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
6:25AM Wednesday 07 January, 2009
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Bill Hoffman Whether taking on developers hell-bent on destroying the Coast’s natural appeal or a Prime Minister indifferent to the plight of the poor, Bill Hoffman has never been one to mince his words. Bill’s been a journalist for 32 years, 29 of those on the Coast. Love him or hate him, he'll get you blogging.

Harmful council power plays

July 16 | Bill Hoffman

The Sunshine Coast Council faced its first important character test last Thursday and failed.

It was disappointing to watch the goodwill that was clearly evident only a few weeks ago disappear in such shameful silence.

The mayor Bob Abbot had the right to expect better of his colleagues who chose a project that he had worked hard over 10 years to deliver, as the vehicle to make their malicious and unenunciated point.

After an 11-2 vote at a general committee meeting on the Monday in favour of additional funding to cover a potential cost blowout in the Cooroy library project, the mayor nor anyone else should have felt the need to be on the phone shoring up the vote protecting a facility desperately needed in the northern hinterland.

Mr Abbot knew from the committee meeting about councillor Chris Thompson’s reservations.

And councillor Anna Grosskreutz did at least rise to her feet to speak to his clumsy motion to re-examine the project. She had also voted against the project in general committee.

But there can be no doubt that someone was very busy on the phone last week.

And there can be no doubt that not one of those who determined to scuttle the project had the intestinal fortitude to knock on the mayor’s door, pick up a telephone nor draw him aside to tell him so before they went into a public forum to humiliate him.

The Cooroy library project had been carefully funded through a combination of land sales, state government grants and savings over time by the old Noosa Council.

With the clock ticking on a $3.5 million state government grant that was contingent on the project delivering fibre optic capacity to enhance business opportunities in the hinterland, any delay has the capacity to kill the project.

Certainly a motion that called for it to be put out for tender to be redesigned, regardless of Mr Thompson’s claim of support for a library with a total cost of $7 million, was potentially fatal.

That the motion contained the qualification that it be redesigned to a scale similar to the Beerwah library was an exercise in envy that seemed ignorant to the fact the southern facility actually has a larger floor plan than that envisaged for Cooroy.

However Mr Thompson aside, last week’s vote wasn’t about libraries, or funding, nor due diligence.

It was instead about fragile egos and weak characters being exploited in a power play that has put aside any chance that, in the short term at least, this council can shake off the corrosive habits of the past.

The matter is now the subject of a rescission motion with the decision to be tested at next Monday’s special meeting to consider future Local Growth Management Strategies.

It can only be hoped that at least one of the councillors who raised their hand in last week’s graceless abuse of trust, will reconsider.

Christian Dickson for one, instead of remembering being roughly put in his place by the mayor two weeks ago, would do better to consider the words that he chose in arguing the need for the whole community to fund the $2.2 million restoration of just the top two water bodies in the failed Chancellor Lakes system.

Mr Dickson rejected any talk of a levy to cover the cost arguing that money had been allocated by the old Maroochy Council.

“We all pay rates,” Mr Dickson said. “We have issues everywhere. Not everyone benefits but everyone pays.’’

Indeed.

The Sunshine Coast community voted overwhelmingly for change earlier this year.

Anything short of a unified regional council with trust and reciprocated respect as its key character traits will not have the capacity to hold off a state government and powerful development lobby who would deny it.

The community wanted leaders who could guide change and deliver policies that recognise and respect their aspirations. It wanted a council that worked as a team, not one driven by factions and egos.

It wanted a council that worked for the community, not councillors who work every opportunity to advance their own ambitions.

There will always be those who remain vulnerable to the exploitation of ignorance, fear and envy.

Last Thursday it became evident that vulnerability extends to this community’s leadership group and that despite this community’s best efforts to flush out of local government those who would exploit it, there remains within its ranks those with that capacity.

And that is a real shame.

Recent Comments

on 16 July, 2008 at 12:30 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Thanks Bill. As usual, you're on the money. Maybe we need a new neologism to describe the petty envy so often levelled at the old Noosa Shire: a trait which is steadily growing amongst some small-minded councillors? How about Noosaphobia? We haven't seen the last of this north-south divide, I'm sure.
on 16 July, 2008 at 6:52 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Yes Bill smacks of payback.... can't have the mega sports facility at caloundra can't have the Libary at Cooroy. I have said before the sooner they dispense with divisions and become councillors for the entire Shire the better . Before amalgamation over 60% of Councils big & small rural & city changed with not one changing back. Councillors are responsible for every decision made & don't resort to the old game play "" they don't vote for me Im only interested in what happens in my division ". Believe me I have experienced it first hand.
Trevor Thompson
Yandina
on 16 July, 2008 at 8:02 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Spot on Bill, just ask Joe Natoli about the "backroom turnaround boys" with their backstabbing ways - they are alive and well, unfortunately. They wouldn't have a clue about decency.The majority of them are having their strings pulled by outside influences who have a different agenda. The scheme works like this - agree in principle, report back, vote as instructed.If you look back at the calibre of some of the candidates in the election, we missed out big time. I wonder what will happen next time??
on 16 July, 2008 at 8:05 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
As unlike me as it is, I have been very retiscent about jumping into this story. I don't know what it is, but something just doesn't gel with the suggestion that this is all about "payback" or the re-emergence of the "old Maroochy style" politics.

Maybe I have been reluctant because I think that Cooroy does need its own library or maybe it's because I cannot imagine that a whole bunch of previously intelligent, rational, co-operative Councillors have suddenly, overnight, been sprinkled with goblin dust and turned into irrational, vengeful, drouling monsters. This happens in Harry Potter books but not in real life.

On reflection I think that my retiscence has been due BOTH to the fact that I think that Cooroy needs a library, AND that I don't quite accept the "payback" story.

So what is behind it? We have heard quite a bit from the pro-library lobby in the Press. Can the Goblins and drouling monsters explain themselves?
on 16 July, 2008 at 9:42 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Excalibur. Maybe it is as simple as it sounds. Maybe the goblins did get at them. Buddy's scenario sounds quite plausible to me based on my experience.
on 16 July, 2008 at 9:44 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Bill should get to more Council meetings if he didn't see this coming. He has chosen to miss the point, burying it as "unenunciated", that Crs Brennan and Green have between them systematically goaded, insulted, demeaned, browbeaten and otherwise put off side all of the other councillors, seven of whom have obviously decided that they've had enough.

That is no comfort to Cooroy whose brilliant and long overdue library is caught up in this showdown, but Bill does not help by pontificating about "fragile egos and weak characters" and "graceless abuse of trust" if he really does hope this impasse is resolved.
on 16 July, 2008 at 1:19 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
I thought Bill's column was on the money but I will say the Noosa phobia thing has been well fuelled by the north, but it is still absolutely no reason not to support a library which highlights what we are dealing with.
on 16 July, 2008 at 2:20 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Don't forget the development lobby who don't want Big Bob (that might explain why he was targeted for an embarrasing public moment).

And don't forget some councillors are in the pockets of the developers.

On the library: every country town needs a decent library, it is the hub of country towns all over the world.

It is the gateway to the world and the community.

We used to have a council library on the Range until it got burnt down and replaced by a community run library.

Yep, funded in the early days by the original motor bike show and now funded by cake stalls and book sales all run by the older members of the community.
on 16 July, 2008 at 4:56 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Save_Bridges should not excuse the extraordinary inaction of the gang of seven , to oppose a community planned action with minimal council debate for their actions indicates a hidden agenda that must be put in the public arena , not hidden discussions by individual councillors to push a party line....
on 18 July, 2008 at 5:45 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Don't blame me, I didn't vote for Chris Thompson who got in down here. Even Champion would have been better.
on 19 September, 2008 at 9:32 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
The voting down of the proposed library for Cooroy is one of the most ignorant decisions I have ever witnessed.Whatever possessed these councillors to deny the very young and their mums an opportunity to come together for a toddlers and baby group in the local library.I recall living on a meager income in a 3rd world country where my husband had taken a position on local wages as part of our committment to education. My most treasured memories are of spending every afternoon where possible in the library with my young daughters and baby. Reading was and reamains our lifeblood and brainfood. I watched my older girls grow through reading and the baby would bounce her arms in rythm to my voice as I read out aloud. This experience is etched in my familys psyche and has helped create beautiful minds and young women. The families in Cooroy could all do with a lift especially the young who one day hopefully will never make such disgracful and ignorant choices when it comes their turn to govern for the public good. If this was payback for two councillors poor behaviour as suggested then this behaviour needs to be publicly outed by the Mayor and other councillors so these alleged behaviours can be addressed.But in the meantime what an injustice to the folk in Cooroy who all deserve equal access to public facilities for the reasons that libraries exist.

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive