Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
8:14PM Wednesday 07 January, 2009
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Bill Hoffman Whether taking on developers hell-bent on destroying the Coast’s natural appeal or a Prime Minister indifferent to the plight of the poor, Bill Hoffman has never been one to mince his words. Bill’s been a journalist for 32 years, 29 of those on the Coast. Love him or hate him, he'll get you blogging.

The Bali bombers pending execution needs a Christian perspective

November 5 | Bill Hoffman

In the midst of all the “will they or won’t they, is it today, tomorrow or next month” examination of the execution of Bali bombers Imam Samudra, Amrozi and Mukhlas, another timebomb ticks.

The death watch in Australia, given that so many of our holiday makers died on Legian Street in 2002, is perhaps understandable.

I also know people who survived the blast, but who can’t escape the horror of the flame-consumed bodies around them.

One mate, who was in the middle of Paddy’s Bar when one of the bombs went off, deconstructed mentally over the phone in a three-hour conversation with me shortly afterwards and has still not been put back together.

There is real doubt he ever will be.

Some of my Kuta mates lost friends and family members and others were called in to retrieve bodies; a process that given their beliefs was terrifying and has depleted them .

But what is lacking in the Australian media’s dissection of how the bombers will be killed, what will happen to their bodies, who will shoot them and how that process will be played out, is any critical analysis of the death penalty itself.

Because it would seem to me paradoxical that in a Christian nation so many of us purport to belong to, there has been so little protest from Christians about what is now unfolding.

It is true that we have no control over the Indonesian judicial process, and nor should we.

However I would have thought that this tragedy presented a wonderful opportunity for Christians to show the depth of their faith.

Doesn’t God forgive? Isn’t He the final arbiter? Don’t Christians learn in the faith’s basic tenets that thou shalt not kill?

If anything should unite the various interpretations that challenge to be the real Christian faith, surely this opportunity to show what sets the religion apart should be it.

In the fractious world of competing “Christian” dogma for some, life is precious from conception. For others, life support should be maintained at all cost.

We get the debate where man determines that some, because of their sexuality, should be denied access to God’s love and that women should be excluded from the pulpit.

But at this moment where Christians’ capacity to forgive - as their God has instructed through the lesson of his own son’s execution at the cross – is being so sorely tested we hear little if nothing from any section of the church arguing for these men’s lives to be spared.

What a wonderful message could have been sent to the extremist muslim minority, what a wonderfully unifying and strengthening voice would a message of forgiveness give to that vast majority of Muslims who just live for peace and to raise happy, healthy families.

It would seem that our unwillingness to practice what we preach has exposed us... found us wanting.

That should give pause for reflection.

That it won’t presents a challenge for all Christians and has not been missed by the hyenas who form the cheer squad for the three murderers.

Lulu Jamaludin, the brother of one of the ring leaders Imam Samudra, is already exploiting our weakness in faith and preparing the ground for our further humiliation.

“The Bali Nine should be the ones to be executed first, don’t let them free, it’s a discrimination,’’ Jamaludin said from Cilacap near the south coast central Java jail.

“The Bali bombers’ actions killed 202, but the Bali Nine killed one generation.’’

What room does our silence and lack of forgiveness leave us to argue for those young fools still on death row to be spared?

Christianity requires more of us than the choice and interpretation of the parables that best suit our prejudices. Until we learn that, regardless of the bluster of our guns and armies in Iraq and Afghanistan, we will remain powerless against those who understand that fundamental flaw.

Recent Comments

on 5 November, 2008 at 5:16 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Good call, and all very true. You have hit the nail on the head.
on 5 November, 2008 at 7:10 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I agree with most of what you've said Bill.

Except that the people that the Bali Bombers killed didn't have any choice in the matter. They weren't given a choice of 'if you go to the Sari Club tonight you might get bombed'.

People who take drugs have made a choice to do so. And in this day and age with all the drug education through the media, schools and the community...it's an informed choice.
on 6 November, 2008 at 8:02 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I am actually sickened by the brutality that a firing squad brings to mind. In this day and age if a criminal is to be executed I think it should all be done by lethal injection. The end result is the same the victims families have a sense of closure and the justice system has done it's job.The appeal system needs to be improved and sped up as well. A firing squad doing the execution in the middle of the night and in an isolated spot seem to suggest to me that perhaps they are ashamed of this method.. I do believe they should be killed but they should not have had to wait for so long. I feel sorry for the families who were not allowed to say their goodbyes, but I feel sorriest for all the families who never got to say goodbye to the ones that were killed in the bomb blast.
on 6 November, 2008 at 9:02 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
What a load of tosh. One Abrahamic religion can help put perspective on a problem caused by another Abrahamic religion?

Man made religion has caused this; Christian and Muslim.
on 6 November, 2008 at 11:52 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I understand your thoughts sunny. But I'm glad there is an appeals process. Particularly so in America where countless people have been freed from death row as result of conclusive evidence being shown that they did not commit the crime for which they had been given the death penalty.

Personally, I can't, and never will, agree with the death penalty where someone's life may taken simply because they didn't have the money to pay for a dna test and/or the money to pay for a decent legal representation.

I also realise plenty of guilty people get off scot-free because they have the money to pay for shrewd, excellent legal representation. But I'd rather a thousand guilty ones go free than one single innocent person be executed.
on 6 November, 2008 at 12:40 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
I cringed this morning when my 6 year old son asked what an execution is. After explaining what it is and why these men will be executed without any hesitation he said to me "Mummy why are they being killed, we should be forgiving them!". Such a profound comment from such a tender age - children are our teachers if we let them be!
on 7 November, 2008 at 8:24 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Bill, thank you for your sermon on your version of Christianity. I suspect you are after some theological outrage to boost your column. Good luck with that.
on 7 November, 2008 at 11:06 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
What about the commandment 'you shall not kill'? Are we any different from the bombers by killing them? Surely a live spent behind bars with hard labour is punishment enough?
Our fasination with this execution is sickening, it is barbaric!
on 7 November, 2008 at 2:53 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
What an exceptional column Bill.
I think all religion is stupid no matter what the faith, but you raise an excellent point. Australia is meant to be a christian nation, god-fearing and all going to heaven for not sinning and that crap. But it amuses me to no end that the noisy christians who demand that same sex relationships suffer unequal treatment have kept their mouth shut about something that is actually one of their commandments.
There is nothing in the ten commandments about boys kissing boys or girls kissing girls, but there is one that says you shall not murder. Hypocrites!
on 9 November, 2008 at 11:18 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Bill Hoffman,

You dont even BELIEVE in Christians, or the Christian witness, or the Chritian founder etc. So how can you feel you have the right to point fingers as them now? Just as a note, behind the scenes Christians are praying for those who were hurt and lost loved ones, praying for the those who killed them, giving and going to places in need all over the world, loving those who hate and abuse them. And Christians are imperfect, no excuse just a statement of fact, so some are angry and some desire revenenge and many need to learn to forgive as they have been forgiven. Not all are out baying for blood or ignoring the plight of the murderers, or the bereved, or the broken, or the needy.

And just to clear up a problem you seem to have - thou shalt not murder - one of the ten commandments (how many know and accept the first?) - is about just that - murder. It does not say thou shalt not kill. Go through some of the Levitical code and see how many instances there are of punishment by death for certain extreme actions (such as the murder of others) and thus not be quite so selective in your comments.
on 9 November, 2008 at 11:23 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Given some of the responses here I wonder what the level of understanding of religion is here in this country. From what I can see our nations leaders HAVE indicated they are in principle opposed to the death penalty. And many actually inside the churches have been praying for those hurt in the bombings, for those families that lost loved ones and friends, and for the bombers as well. And again - do many even KNOW the commandments. Can you list all ten? Do you even know the first? Where are your crys for the Christians dying in India for nothing other than being Christian? Hundreds dead and little mention from our press. Why is that I wonder?

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive