'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Is It Just Me? Caroline Hutchinson has been the husky voice on breakfast radio on the Coast for a decade. Always one with a heart for a good cause, she's also the driving passion behind 92.7 Mix FM’s successful Give Me Five for Kids campaign which has raised more than $1 million for sick kids.

Parents killing their children

July 11 | Caroline Hutchinson

Is it just me or has everyone learned a new word this week?

My word is filicide and I wish I never heard it.

It means the deliberate act by a parent of killing his or her child.

None of us will forget the faces of Jack, Maddie and Bon Bell, the gorgeous kids gassed to death by their dad because he thought he might be going to jail for repeatedly beating their mother. His final act of brutality.

Garry Bell had a history of violence. Members of his own family were frightened of him.

Neighbours say he often locked his wife Karen out of the house at night and had been seen kicking her out of the family car, insisting she follow himself and the children on foot.

Until the day he killed them all, Garry Bell had never laid a finger on any of his children.

In the same week the Bell children died, a 31-year-old Cowra policewoman lost her sons and mother in a triple axe murder committed by her dad.

Then there’s Susan Smith, the American woman who drove her car into a lake, watched her two boys drown, then claimed a car-jacking.

And Gavin Hall, who suffocated his three-year-old daughter Millie as revenge for his wife’s infidelity.

In a text message, he told her: ‘Now you have the rest of your life to deal with the consequences'.

There’s thousands more cases, I know. UK authorities claim every ten days in England and Wales a parent kills a child.

The Australian Institute of Criminology claims filicide makes up 17% of all domestic homicide nationwide.

It is committed almost equally by mums and dads. Motivation for filicide differs, however.

Women who murder their children usually do it in the first years of life, for reasons ranging from altruistic filicide, that is, murder motivated by ‘love’ because they no-longer feel they can care for their child, to fatal maltreatment filicide, including abuse, neglect and Munchausen syndrome by proxy.

Experts claim in almost all cases of altruistic filicide the mother has sought help of some sort.

As such, a new mother who claims to be depressed should never be ignored.

Doctors are now advised to make immediate but discreet inquiries about how a depressed mother ‘feels’ about the child, and insist on a follow up appointment.

It’s interesting to note that across the world, women are responsible for just 14% of violent crime, yet 50% of filicide.

Dads who murder their children are more likely to commit multiple filicide, involving older children, motivated by depression, mental illness or spousal revenge.

Twenty-five per cent of dads who kill have sought some sort of psychiatric help.

In the case of spousal revenge however, experts claim filicide is almost impossible to predict.

I was disappointed this week to read one opinion piece calling for more understanding of men who kill their kids, especially as the result of marriage breakdown.

“That loss of control is deeply wounding to male pride. It can easily curdle into murderous jealousy if their own flesh and blood ends up living with another male.”

I have no doubt separation is horrific for families, but paternal filicide is no argument for changes to the family court.

The very fact children have been killed is proof the courts got it right, they were clearly not safe with their father.

Having said that, I agree the only way to prevent more spousal revenge killings is to acknowledge the distress of some dads and attempt to do something about it.

The NSW ombudsman has called for a national taskforce. He says until we can establish a pattern in domestic homicide, health care workers, social workers and police are floundering in the dark.

But no matter how much you blame the courts or the government, no matter what is going on in your life, remember this – if you have ever, even once considered or planned killing your children, it is time to ask for help.

Call Lifeline on 13 11 14

Recent Comments

on 11 July, 2008 at 9:35 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Irrespective of the reason used for parents killing their children I strongly believe they must be sterilised before release from prison. They have no rights to have more children to torture and kill.
on 11 July, 2008 at 2:01 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
When I was in Yr 12 at school I had to read the Greek tragedy 'Medea' by Euripides. Written in 431BC, it examines the revenge of a woman betrayed by her husband. In considering infanticide she muses, "Why should I seek to wring their father's heart, When that same act will doubly wring my own". Nevertheless, she carries out the slaying of her two sons to cause maximum grief to her unfaithful spouse. Unfortunately, these acts have not been confined to the pages of ancient literature, and it appears we sometimes remain most dangerous to those we 'love'.
on 11 July, 2008 at 2:44 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
In the end most of these acts are the last act of control, which will stand long after they are gone leaving an impact on/against their partner/family to which they have no recourse.

It is a sad savage act which no one wins.
on 11 July, 2008 at 5:26 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
heggiehawk...your comments are both insightful and well researched. Congrats.

Unfortunately, after all the wringing of hands, tears and accusations, the children always lose.

But as a last act of defiance/sense I offer the following from my old Mum - 'there, but for the grace of God, go I'.
on 11 July, 2008 at 10:30 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
It is tragic that the Bell children died, what I don't understand is why our young women still stay with men like this, Mrs Bell had been with this man for 5 years before she decided to have children. Knowing what she knew and what this man was obviously doing to her before the children came along, why make the choice to even bring those precious little babies into the world.

I know the old comment but she loved him, she was scared yadda yadda yadda. I am sure that if my mother had of stayed away long enough on the many occasions she left my abusive father she may have saved herself from becoming a nightly punching bag and saved us from living in fear every day for many years of our lives. As hard as we try we are still bringing up girls to believe that they have to tolerate this gross behaviour from their partners, so sad because it is always the children who suffer or pay the ultimate price. Too sad that Mrs Bell now has to live with the choices she and she alone made.
on 12 July, 2008 at 8:49 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Amlonmyown. I to grew up in a volatile home and left a husband when I had 2 babies as I could see the signs and didn't want my children to grow up in fear. There are no winners in this type of situation and the people with serious anger issues like this are very manipulative and cunning in their control of others. The same as paedophiles are. It's usually the mind games that have women/men trapped and not always women experience this type of violence in a partnership. With the threat of violence to themselves or people they love and sometimes even the pets people feel they have to stay to protect others the stripping of their self esteem is the best prisoner. After years of this immense fear they have no self worth left only fear that's why I believe alot of people don't walk when they know they owe it to their children to walk and must live in constant turmoil. The best we can do is report abuse if we know of it, be empathetic towards the victims and understand that our children are gifts and watch out for others. It's tragic that Karen Bell finally found herself enough to try and give her children a better life only for this to happen to her.
on 17 July, 2008 at 4:38 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Unfortunately, unless you have been through a similar DV situation, it is hard to comprehend the whys. Why she stayed, why she had kids, why he did it....

It shows just what cowards these men really are, they use their power to control their partners, and then when the day of reckoning comes (ie being found out/charged etc) they cant handle it and do such things as this man did. They have lost their power and the true colours come out.

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive