Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
7:11PM Sunday 07 September, 2008 Sunshine Coast weather Mostly sunny min 10° - max 23°
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Is It Just Me? Caroline Hutchinson has been the husky voice on breakfast radio on the Coast for a decade. Always one with a heart for a good cause, she's also the driving passion behind 92.7 Mix FM’s successful Give Me Five for Kids campaign which has raised more than $1 million for sick kids.

Parents, butt out of school

June 20 | Caroline Hutchinson

Is it just me or does everyone think the modern parent is sometimes a kid's worst enemy?

A friend of mine was a teacher in the western suburbs of Sydney for around 15 years. While others did their time and got out as fast as they could, Luke stuck at it.

Part P.E. teacher, part social worker, he believed in the kids and loved his job.

A couple of years ago, at the final bell one Friday as kids and teachers began streaming out of classrooms looking for a short cut home, a group of Year 10 girls passed Luke on the stairs.

Laughing and joking, one of them made a grab for the pens in Luke’s top pocket.

He was a relatively young, good looking teacher, he liked to joke with the kids and he felt he had a good rapport with them.

So he swatted her hand and kept moving. Suddenly there were ten girls who wanted the pens – amidst cheering and giggling and Luke was swamped.

Never one to back down from a challenge, as the pens were grabbed and lifted victoriously, he hit back – seized the pen snatchers wrist and backed her up against a wall.

To more cheers and lots more boos he plucked the pens from her hand.

Long story short, later that evening the police visited his home to discuss allegations of assault.

The 15-year-old had told her dad that Luke had ‘crushed’ her wrist and humiliated her.

Her Dad demanded an apology, Luke’s dismissal and financial compensation for the effect the injury would have on his daughter’s study.

The rumour mill began to grind and it eventually made the papers, with headlines like “student assault” complete with testimony from the standard disgruntled parents.

Luke was stood down pending an investigation.

In the end, the charges didn’t make it to court, however the family received an official apology and Luke was offered a job at a different school. He didn’t take it.

This week the Victorian Principals Association issued a plea to parents to “butt out” of their children’s education.

The Teachers Federation claims hundreds of Queensland teachers are under investigation because of parent complaints they yell too much.

As a parent, there is nothing I hate more than being stopped in the car park and whinged to about what is going on at school.

Across the board kids are offered a fantastic education these days and I have a lot of faith in the schools my kids attend.

If I didn’t, I wouldn’t bitch and moan for a second. I would simply re-enrol them somewhere else (where I suspect I would find the same mix of good, bad, relaxed, crabby, funny, kind and yelly teachers).

No doubt my kids like some teachers more than others but I don’t give it much thought.

If “being grumpy” is how a Year 10 science teacher gets through her day - locked in a classroom with 30 adolescents - that’s her bad luck.

The way I see it, going to school is my children’s job, just like their dad and I have a job.

It’s regularly boring and sometimes you get into trouble for doing the wrong thing.

Sometimes you get into trouble because someone else did something wrong and you copped the blame. Suck it up, Tiger.

It’s not always fair or fun, but it is life and the quicker you learn to play by the rules, the happier you’ll be.

Parents who allow their kids to turn every perceived slight or injustice into a federal case are fools. Far from protecting their children from harm, they are setting them up for a lifetime of petty battles.

You can’t manage every minute of your child’s day. And you certainly can’t trust them to tell the whole truth about what happens in the classroom.

When parents get involved, they can easily get it wrong and suddenly allegations and finger pointing take on a life of their own.

My friend Luke lost a lot more than his job when a parent got it wrong, but so did the Department of Education. They lost Luke and, I suspect, a lot more like him along the way.

Recent Comments

on 20 June, 2008 at 8:49 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Caroline, your husky voice hammers this one home 100%.

We're ruining our own society, our own freedoms - and our own ability to have a laugh and enjoy our days - by perpetuating this ridiculous American idea of lawsuits for every perceived slight.

Parents suing teachers, kids suing parents - it's ridiculous and the only way to end it is by throwing this rubbish out of court immediately, and fining the pathetic, petty people instigating these suits for wasting taxpayers money - our money.
on 20 June, 2008 at 9:42 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I only finished school a few years ago and I can clearly remember all of my teachers. Some were really awesome, funny, insightful and generally really good people...others were hell on legs, yelling, screaming and carrying on, but ultimately they all did their jobs, and did them well, teaching us everything we needed to know.

As in all schools, there was a certain male teacher that MANY of the girls had a crush on. And as with many imaginative school girls, these girls mistook day to day converstion as flirting on many occasions. Thank goodness that these girls didn't go home to mum and dad saying 'oooh Mr soandso was flirting so much with me today' because they would've been down to the school in a split second, accusing said teacher of having inappropriate relationships with their daughter when clearly that wasn't occuring.

It all seems to be a massive game of chinese whispers. Teacher says or does something completely innocent, student takes it as something it isn't (flirting for example), runs home to mummy and daddy and tells them what happened, mum and dad report to school something completely different again. This is a huge concern because many great teachers, who connect well with students, are being accused of wrongdoing, often (as is obviously the case with your friend Luke) pushing them out of the teacher profession completely... lets face it, we really cant afford to lose any more great teachers. I think parents should take a pace back, look at things a little bit more reasonably, and let teachers do their jobs the way that they do them best...albeit with a joke and a pat on the back or yelling and detention.

Remember its not hard for "hi, how ya doin?" to be turned into "purple monkey dishwasher"
on 20 June, 2008 at 10:59 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
As always, Caroline, I agree with your above article 100%. The world has become way too americanized, with people suing each other left right and centre. Everyone is looking for someone to blame and take revenge on, and an opportunity to make some easy cash at the expense of someone elses life and career. It's pathetic. What happened to kindness and common decency?!?
on 20 June, 2008 at 1:34 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
I agree with you Caroline, well said. Kids are not being prepared for the 'real world' when parents fight their fights. Things can be blown right out of proportion. The only thing I would say is - teachers need to identify when they are 'over it' and move on to something else.
on 20 June, 2008 at 5:33 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
I agree with what you say BUT there are two sides (at least) to every story.

I've recently had a visitor, a teacher from another state. I told her a story and she confirmed that there are far too many teachers in the system who she describes as mentally unstable. These people are damaging children too.

A lot of parents know when there is something not right but they don't know what or who is wrong because no-one will say. The teachers stick together and the parents never know until it is to late to help their kids cope with the mentally unstable teacher.

The whole thing needs sorting out.
on 20 June, 2008 at 8:01 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Caroline I agree 100% with what you say. As for savetherange's comments go I would say, yes, no doubt there are two sides to every story, but the way children are treated these days they think that they can do no wrong and if they do there will be no repercussions. I don't blame our teachers for giving up, they cannot chastise the kids without facing prosecution. They face a hopeless task.

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive