Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
2:59PM Wednesday 03 December, 2008
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Mark My Words Mark, editor-in-chief of the Sunshine Coast Daily, has been a journalist on the Coast for 20 years and is passionate about fighting for a better deal for the region. When he's not at work, he loves nothing more than spending time with his wife Julie and three kids.

When will we learn that one punch can kill?

April 1 | Mark Furler

It seems we have a long way to go in this country to learn the lesson that one punch can kill, if the reaction to the Nick D’Arcy affair is anything to go by.

It wasn’t long ago on the Sunshine Coast that there was an outcry over the death of a promising young Caloundra man, Josh Mill, after he was allegedly punched to death in the main street of the CBD.

Yet yesterday on talkback radio and on the Daily’s website, many were pleading for Nick D’Arcy to be spared the “horrible penalty” of being banned from going to the Olympics after he allegedly broke a former swimmer’s jaw and nose in a pub brawl in Sydney on the weekend.

On radio, the almost universal reaction was that banning D’Arcy from the Olympics would be too harsh a penalty for the rising young star.

I don’t know Nick D’Arcy at all – and really it doesn’t matter what sort of bloke he is.

The bottom line is, what sort of message will it send to young, impressionable fans if he is found guilty and action is not taken?

But should D’Arcy, a 20-year-old, be the vehicle for that message?

What about all the other sporting heroes who have repeatedly let us down over recent times?

We have had many, much older and supposedly more mature, sporting role models setting terrible examples for young fans.

But should we really be surprised?

Are they not just a symptom of what is a much wider societal problem.

The problem with young people drinking in this country goes way beyond one night involving Nick D’Arcy celebrating his hard-earnt admission to the Australian Olympic team.

As has been highlighted by other shocking cases both in Queensland, and interstate, when you combine excessive amounts of alcohol or drugs with anger, the results can be devastating – even with just one punch.

And as a community we have a collective responsibility to better understand that – and to teach our young that violence is never acceptable and that the consequences can be life-changing.

I feel for the D’Arcy family. By all accounts, his parents are good people who have done the hard yards to raise their son right and help him to achieve sporting excellence beyond which most of us could dream.

While it would be easy for Olympic officials to use young Nick as a messenger for their no-violence mandate, I wonder whether it is fair to him – or more particularly his family and supporters.

If the allegations against the young swimmer are proven, it may be punishment enough that he knows he has let down himself, his family and the wider community.

For Olympic officials, a number of issues come into play.

As AAP senior sports writer John Coomber noted yesterday, Australia’s Olympic bosses have a serious dilemma on their hands, regardless of whether D’Arcy is found guilty of assault.

He points out the legal process is unlikely to have have run its course by the time D’Arcy is scheduled to join his team-mates at the pre-Games camp in Kuala Lumpur on July 23.

Even more pressingly, there is a team camp in Canberra on April 23, two days after D’Arcy is scheduled to make his first court appearance.

The AOC now has to weigh D’Arcy’s presumption of innocence against the wider interests of the team as a whole.

It has a duty of care towards the other 450 or so members of the Olympic team, whose best interests it represents.

This is why it has moved to hold its own investigation, jointly with Swimming Australia, before the court process gets underway.

AOC president John Coates, a lawyer, knows this one decision has the potential to be one of the trickiest in his long career.

Regardless of the outcome, the message out of all of this is that we must play a more active role in teaching our kids the terrible consequences that come with excessive drinking and resorting to violence.

And we have to make real inroads into a culture which says we celebrate sporting success and achievement with heavy drinking.

Australian swimming has, in comparison to other sporting codes, had few scandals involving excessive alcohol consumption.

It would be a tragic if such a clean-looking sport starts to adopt the sort of behaviour seen by some of the participants in football codes.

We owe our kids a better legacy than to teach them that excessive alcohol and violence is acceptable in any form.

Recent Comments

on 1 April, 2008 at 6:47 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I agree with you on this one it was an act of violence and should be delt with accordingly no matter who the person was that dealt the blow.Who wants someone like that to represent our country at an Olympic level , though all the facts must be taken into concideration and how much has been distorted by the media in the process?

My thoughts are with his parents as it must be soul destroying to have a child involved in a situation as violent as this one seems to be.

- You're right. We really don't have a clear picture of exactly what happened in this particular case. There are obviously a lot more facts to emerge once both parties reveal their sides to police. - Editor
on 1 April, 2008 at 7:01 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Well written Mark... The kid needs to learn a lesson from this and take responsibility for his actions. May seem a tough call to some but if found guilty, he must be stood down from the team. His actions cannot be condoned.

If the man who was punched died from his injuries which does happen (eg David Hookes), the result would have been much more serious than missing a sporting event.
http://www.onepunchcankill.com.au/
on 1 April, 2008 at 7:20 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
An elbow strike is different to a punch. Does Nick D’Arcy have martial arts training?

I agree with you post except your inclusion of an unqualified dig at drugs. Yet to read or witness incidents of recreational cannabis or ecstasy users engaging in violence without also consuming alcohol or methamphetamines. If you have evidence of such cases, then you might have a point.
on 1 April, 2008 at 10:02 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I'm a sportsman therefore I can do the following:

1. Get in a bar fight and cause grievous bodily harm to another team player and maybe still be a Olympian!!!!
2. I can get drunk and rape woman and get let off
3. I can urinate in the streets
4. I can take drugs and still play football
5. I can take drugs, get drunk and assault women
6. I can get drunk, take drugs and sleep with my best mate's wife

This is the message we are sending out to our kids...
on 1 April, 2008 at 10:05 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
And Jason from Pomona long term cannabis & ecstasy use causes depression & anxiety and can even cause people to be suicidal!!!!

GET OFF THE POT
on 1 April, 2008 at 10:31 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
We see a pattern of this type of behavior in the youngsters of today.
But who knows how the figures stack up, in times past these incidents were dealt with in-house and not much gained the media attention of today.

I in no way condone what Nick allegedly did.....BUT where was Swimming Australia in all of this ?

You have, just like in many professional sports, a bunch of highly trained, highly charged, highly strung, elite athletes; in a pressure cooker situation achieving a milestone.
Now there is oodles of testosterone there and we all know that testosterone is what makes these people tick.

Swimming Australia had all these ticking time bombs out on the town looking for release after the meet. Surely they must realise at the AIS, that these kids need minders more so than some of our older football players.

Unfortunately the governing body has taken no responsibility for unleashing such an ugly scenario.
Where is their management policy, where were the minders and why is this allowed to occur in an uncontrolled situation?

Once again I in no way condone what Nick allegedly did.

But Swimming Australia must be naive to unleash their charges back into society after such a high with out expecting the resulting low.
What happened to the warm down?
on 1 April, 2008 at 11 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Well said Mark. Totally agree. I commented on this story in another news website yesterday and said he is a '20 year old hot head who does not deserve to be in the Olympic swimming team going to Beijing'. Do not reward this idiot, give his place to someone who DOES deserve it. What he did to Cowley is reprehensible and it was obviously a beating, not just one punch either! Adrenaline, testosterone, alcohol fueled stupidity can so easily lead to death, sadly, as we have seen in the past.
on 1 April, 2008 at 11:11 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I apologise for commenting before I had read all news on this story. It was allegedly one almighty punch. The injuries were just I would expect in a beating. An elbow has been mentioned, 12 drinks have been mentioned. We will just have to wait for it all to come out in the weeks ahead.
on 1 April, 2008 at 11:19 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
As a society we need to make binge drinking and drug use unpopular. At present it is accepted and tolerated and now we see the consequences.
on 1 April, 2008 at 6:07 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Brook from Cotton Tree, the topic is alleged alcohol induced violence by a young swimmer. It's a long time since I used any illegal drugs, so no need to get hysterical.
on 3 April, 2008 at 12:45 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
The man/boy should be given a long jail sentence if found guilty and even if not he should be banned from representing the country at the Olympics.
His best bet is to take an alcohol management and temper management course and cure his habit of allegedly going to violence when disagreed with.
He seems to have a history of reacting violently when he is disagreed with, this is taken from comments by persons who know him.
on 3 April, 2008 at 5:44 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Maybe it's time that this sort of assault was treated a bit more seriously, like it is in some European countries, as attempted murder. It's time we grew up as a society and placed priorities where they need to be. That would make some hot heads think twice before drinking and swinging a punch. It is disgusting that on some of the news articles some bloggers have advocated doing the same as Nick allegedly did if in a similar situation.

Turn the other cheek, violence is not worth it. Society needs to be very clear about it priorities. After the outcry about alcohol induced violence at Coast night spots, the Police reacted with drug busts, very Sir Joh and very backward/redneck.

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive