Sub Main Menu
news
sport
lifestyle
entertainment
business
property
2:56PM Wednesday 03 December, 2008
'Blogs Central
Blog Central: Mark My Words Mark, editor-in-chief of the Sunshine Coast Daily, has been a journalist on the Coast for 20 years and is passionate about fighting for a better deal for the region. When he's not at work, he loves nothing more than spending time with his wife Julie and three kids.

How healthy is Biggest Loser?

February 26 | Mark Furler

It’s getting a little depressing watching the Biggest Loser lately.

Each week, we see a succession of big blokes and beefy women bemoaning the fact that they have “only lost” two or three kilograms. It’s enough to send you into a binge-eating fit of depression.

As some of you may know, a couple of weeks ago I insanely joined a quest to lose 20 kilos in 20 weeks or fork out $100 for every kilo I fail to shed.

In my first week, I lost three kilograms, but if you look at my TV counterparts, I should be slashing my wrists rather than quietly celebrating with a little more zest in my step as I slog my way up Woombye’s hernia-inducing hills.

As I may have mentioned, I kicked off my weight-loss program just before the start of the new year and since then have lost about 13 kilos.

In many ways, I think starting out early could prove costly. As my fellow losers continue to offload the kilos, my fear is that my weight loss will start to plateau – unless, of course, I up the exercise, or turn my two meal replacement shakes a day into three or no replacements at all.

When you see these big guys shedding 10 or more kilos a week, you have to wonder whether Biggest Loser is really promoting a sensible or sustainable weight loss.

What am I thinking? It’s television; it’s not about informing or educating people – it’s about ratings.

And watching fat people sweat for hours on end – and then almost cry as they lose 0.9 of a kilo – is great TV. But it’s not particularly helpful.

Most experts say you should try to lose about a kilo a week.

According to the same experts, one of the reasons why contestants on the Biggest Loser are losing so much is because they ate so much to start with.

Whereas big blokes like me are happy to consume 2000 calories a day, these guys and girls are knocking back 3000 calories a day – so the idea of cutting their intake by 1500 calories a day is entirely feasible.

And of course, they’re spending about three hours every day exercising. I don’t know about you, but I struggle to find the hour a day I’m trying to set aside for either gym, walking, or more pain and suffering on the treadmill I foolishly bought months ago.

Despite my early success on the program, somehow I fear I could be a safe bet for anyone who wants to throw some money my way for sponsorship.

Dollars per kilo lost donated by the public will go to two Coast-based charity projects – one involves an orphanage built by the Reed Charity Foundation in India while the other is for a medical centre being developed by Dr Michael Ryan and wife Cheryl.

Pledges can be sent to mark.furler@scnews.com.au .

Recent Comments

on 26 February, 2008 at 6:39 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Perhaps you should have a word to that John Morrall. He managed it. Why can't you (and I for that matter)?

- Thanks for those encouraging words atapro... Editor
on 26 February, 2008 at 9:50 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Mark, I think the Biggest Loser is me for watching that show! I am hopelessly addicted.

I find it amusing that the people there don't realise they lose so much weight initially due to finally eating properly and doing a little excerise. Losing 3kg a week is a good result, but maybe they are told to play it up a little for the cameras?

The contestents have unrealistic expectations which may be fed to them by the producers.

If they are their own expectations then I think its a result of poor education from the trainers and the show itself. I bet Jenny Craig and Weight Watchers don't place those burdens on people who diet the normal way without all of us watching them and judging them!

If only I could stop watching...........

- I normally have a look at it with my wife - and then go for a VERY LONG walk... MF

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments are moderated, should be on-topic and not abusive