Father John Dobson is not only regional dean of the Catholic Church on the Coast but also
the Chancellor of the University of the Sunshine Coast. The well educated priest challenges us all to be slow to condemn and more tolerant of others’ viewpoints. Global warming finger pointing
| Father John Dobson
Global warming and greenhouse gases have now risen to prominence in the political spectrum. It seems that all politicians, either willingly or unwillingly, have to address these issues in a positive way.
It fascinates me that even in this highly important matter, we have the infantile approach of trying to blame someone else as being worse than we are, and so lessening our own responsibility. It is the same trick that squabbling schoolboys use: “He started it, and is worse than I am!”
Already, the leaders of the Western world are pointing the finger at China and India as being major contributors to industrial pollution, trying to shift the focus somewhere else and so absolve them from taking action.
There is no question that these countries are sources of major global pollution. The question is, why is this so?
It seems to me that these emerging nations in the industrial scene are very keen to buy our coal at the best price possible for us, so they can have the cheapest possible energy for their factories.
The factories may well be reasonably primitive, relatively cheap to build and operate. More than likely they are employing labour at a much cheaper price than we would deem acceptable in our society.
Because of this they are in a position to manufacture goods much cheaper than we can do in our more sophisticated and somewhat more costly manufacturing systems. How many industries have we lost in Australia to cheaper manufacturing countries?
When this is mixed with our appetite to buy goods at the cheapest possible price, not only have we developed a global market, we have also developed a global problem built on inequality. Global trade rarely operates on a level playing field.
It seems to me that the vast majority of goods and products we buy in our Australian stores are, in fact, manufactured in China and other such countries. We do this to make use of the cheapest possible means of production. China is simply meeting our needs in the cheapest possible way. But is it cheap in the long run?
While our political leaders are finger-pointing at these emerging manufacturing countries with their cheaper means of production, the real question is, are we a part of this problem, or is it all the fault and responsibility of the Chinese and other such nations?
Do they alone have to contain their greenhouse emissions and “fix the problem” or do we, the Western world, have some responsibility here because we are the consumers who make it happen?
As in most areas of life, it is possibly a time for joint responsibility and not just divisive finger-pointing.




Not Registered? Quick registration and comment.





Recent Comments
You mention the vast majority of goods and products we buy in our Australian stores are, in fact, manufactured in China & poorer countries that don't tax as harshly as our government,
and the consumer buys these goods without inquiring if there is other goods available that are produced here in Australia.
To calculate the amount of energy, used, say for instance in making a shirt in Asia to you buying it, we must include the cost of growing the cotton here in Australia, exporting it to China, then having it woven in their mills, then say Vietnam sewers buy the cloth, transport costs, and so forth add to the energy costing.
I don’t understand how we can believe that we are getting these goods at a bargain as in a few short years the lack of a cotton crop will have a huge effect on the total cost of your shirt. As I live in the vicinity where Cotton was a big exporter, the past couple of years there has been a small crop or no crop produced here in the irrigation areas of Emerald.
You could revert to the good old days when you or your mother mended the seam, patched the tear and generally took good care of the garment that was hand-washed and line dried, thus adding to the life of the garment.