9:54a.m. 25th July 2008
You can call your children what you like – as long as they're not named after Adolf Hitler, the Antichrist or anything likely to embarrass them in the playground.
A Family Court judge in New Zealand has ruled that a New Plymouth couple burdened their child with a "social disability and handicap" when they named her "Talula Does The Hula From Hawaii".
Judge Rob Murfitt ordered temporary court custody for the nine-year-old to ensure a proper name was found for her.
The girl said she was so embarrassed that she had not revealed her name to any of her friends.
"She fears being mocked and teased, and in that she has a greater level of insight than either of her parents," said Judge Murfitt.
The story follows a controversy which erupted last year when the New Zealand Department of Internal Affairs ruled a couple could not name their baby boy 4Real - so they threatened to call him Superman instead.
New Zealand Internal Affairs spokesman Tony Wallace said this week that unless names caused offence, were more than 100 characters long or used an official title, there was no reason not to register them.
"It's not for us to determine whether a name should or should not be registered because it's unusual or funny ... It's whether it's offensive to a reasonable person," he said.
However, Children's Commissioner Cindy Kiro lamented the "ridiculous" lack of insight some parents had into the effect the wrong name could have on their children.
Other New Zealand children have been given names such as Number 16 Bus Shelter, Violence and Benson and Hedges (twins).
Bloggers on the New Zealand Herald website were divided over the issue, with some agreeing that giving children inappropriate names was a form of abuse, while others arguing that the judge’s ruling was political correctness gone mad.
What do you think? Should parents be able to name their children whatever they wish or are some names simply unacceptable?
Recent Comments
Who would determine a good name from a bad one?
I bet Michael Hunt's parents thought it was a good old sensible name at the time too. But I bet he copped just as much flak at school as anyone. Personally, I think I would prefer Benson… or Hedges.
Kids only learn this judgmental attitude from adults. Why can't everyone be accepted for who they are & be respected regardless of their name? That is the hallmark of a tolerant, accepting society.
I thought we were evolving & getting past this stuff. With so many freedoms being eroded, naming your child should be your right as a caring human parent.
If their given names cause them so much grief, children can always modify them as they grow up through abbreviation or nicknames & legally change their names once they reach adulthood. On the other hand, some children actually thank their parents for putting thought & effort in & they revel in their individuality & use it to their advantage in life.
I feel more for all those with names that sound relatively normal when spoken (Bianca) but have unusual spelling when written, (Beanka)so they grow up having to spell their names out letter by letter every time they need to say their name or write it down. I'm sure that's more of a drag.
Have your say
We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments should be on-topic and not abusive. Comments are checked before publication.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts
Your comments will be checked, for legal reasons, before being posted live.
Thanks again for contributing to the Daily's online community.
We value your views.
Comment again