Sub Main Menu
sunshine coast
noosa
coolum
national
world
5:48AM Sunday 23 November, 2008 Sunshine Coast weather Mostly sunny min 17° - max 25°

Veteran builder hits out at new charge

The man behind Coast building giant PJ Burns is furious at the lack of affordable housing on the Sunshine Coast.

Rick Burns said the situation would only worsen when changes to the state government’s payroll tax system come into effect on July 1.

The change will cause the cost of building a new home to rise by more than $3000, according to an independent report by Queensland Master Builders.

Companies which pay more than $1 million a year in wages currently pay a payroll tax of 4.75%.

Under the new system, sub-contractors who do a majority of their work with one company will be considered employees, which would mean more companies would hit the $1 million mark.

Mr Burns, who has been building on the Coast for 30 years, said he would have no choice but to pass the fee on to his customers.

“That’s what worries me,” he said.

“How can a state government talk about housing affordability and then add in a bill of $3400 (per house)? It just doesn’t add up.”

However, Mr Burns said he did not expect to see a drop in the number of houses built on the Sunshine Coast.

“It’ll just put the price of houses up, and it’ll put the price of second-hand houses up too,” he said.

“The reason second-hand houses have gone through the roof is because new houses and land have been so dear.”

Mr Burns said while he would not be personally affected by the rise, he hated passing increases on to his customers.

He said more land should be released for development to make building a home more affordable.

Andrew and Jenny Harries, just weeks away from the completion of a four-bedroom home at Bellflower, were relieved to have missed the increase.

“That would have devastated us,” Mr Harries said.

“Most people building a new home have a set budget and it’s really important that the building company and the client stick to that budget.

“It’s another nail in the coffin as far as how far you can stretch your resources.”

Master Builders director of construction John Crittall said the building industry had already “cooled down” on the Coast, and the extra fee would make the situation worse.

Master Builders has asked for a 12-month moratorium on the legislation so that it would come into effect on July 1, 2009.

It has also requested a further amnesty to allow the industry time to implement changes to adapt to the “extremely complex” legislation.

Deputy opposition leader Fiona Simpson said the opposition had strongly opposed the legislation in parliament.

FEES AND CHARGES

Federal

GST and company tax adds about 50% to the taxes on a new home. In 2005 on a new house and land package in Maroochy Shire company tax was $14,703 and GST was $34,363.

State

Infrastructure Charges are about 5% to 6% of the total cost, with stamp duty, council rates, land tax, council fees, compliance and approval costs, holding costs from council added on. When you add stamp duty to the purchase price it amounts to another $7750.

Noosa council

Water, sewerage, public open space, coastal major road network, pathway trunk network, stormwater drainage fees and charges amount to $21,358.

Maroochy council

Water, sewerage, public parks, roads, bikeways and bicycle facilities, stormwater quality and land for community facilities fees and charges amount to $17,038.

Council fees are yet to be amalgamated, Caloundra figures were not available. Information provided by UDIA.

Recent Comments

Add a comment
on 22 May, 2008 at 12:09 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
What do people expect from a labor government.
on 22 May, 2008 at 1:13 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Howard with hair.
on 22 May, 2008 at 2:05 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
its about time the subbie scam loophole was closed. this might stop firms laying off workers and then hiring them as sub contractors.

as for PJ Burns crying foul - I bet that company was one of the first to lay off its workers when the subbie scam loophole first opened up
on 22 May, 2008 at 6:41 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I'm not a political person or much chop at maths but even I can see the growing trend of our state and federal governments to totally ignore or disregard what we the voters want. It has seemed to me over the past few years that the people we elect to serve us ignore the vast majority of us who do not want certain things to go ahead as they will make life that much harder for most. Whatever has happened to the voice of the common people? Will we be forever ignored while the power hungry and the greed for more and more money in both state and federal coffers goes on. In hindsight I can now see why the many questions I asked and letters I sent to Mr Rudd and Mr Swan on the Pensioners plight were never answered or even acknowledged. Perhaps it was an error to elect a PM who has no real concept of what it is like to have to do without the basics of life.A roof over your head, a warm bed, decent food on the table, a new coat and a new pair of shoes that no one else has worn. These are the rights of every man woman and child.
on 22 May, 2008 at 7:13 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
The whole thing is about closing a subbie loophole. A loophole that is exploited by companies to avoid paying there subbies (for all intents and purposes employees) holiday pay,sick pay, super, workcover. They pass all these costs on to the subbie and make themselves even more money. This is a good change that is trying to address this issue. While yet again the development industry trots out its standard mantra - "we need more land to make cheaper houses" I'm sorry but what a load of crap.
on 22 May, 2008 at 7:23 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I have always said what the Federal Government gives you in the one hand, the State Government will work out how to take it back in the other.

It will be interesting when then State Government Budget comes down what other surprises will be in store.

Stamp Duty is a rort.
on 22 May, 2008 at 8:09 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
now that this part of the subbie loophole has been closed employers will be forced to start to pay holiday pay, sick leave, maternity leave, workers comp etc etc etc

the likes of PJ Burns have had a free run at the expense of the worker for too long.
on 22 May, 2008 at 9:21 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Fiona Simpson needs to explain why she thinks some tradespeople should not enjoy the benefits she takes for granted, ie. , holiday pay, sick pay and insurance etc. I would argue some of these people are more qualified and more productive than many of Fiona's mates in the parliament.

My neighbour (with 3 children) is a competent tradesman. He tells me he works for $25 ph. No hols, no super, no insurance, no sickies and when there is no work, no pay. After tax, payment for insurance, sick days and other days without pay he makes less than a shop assistant.

The Nationals, first in line at the porkbarrel, last in line for the fair go.
on 22 May, 2008 at 10:01 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Ed, When I consider the comments from sunnyone- 44 from Mooloolaba, how true. For too many years now, we've sat on our backsides and allowed governments including local councils to do what they want and have clearly ignored the needs of the majority. When I look at the pathetic state-of-affairs to the S.W of my home location, this being, Brisbane; how can people live in that city when the infrastructure problems are worsening? Even in my local area, we have the hunger of property owners selling for unit development and the backyard is disappearing to when I first settled here. Now we have an interesting statement from P.J Burns and he's entitled to be angry at the Queensland Government's costs. Earlier this morning, I forwarded a email to our Prime Minister requesting information on what he and his government are going to do - in addition to their home saving account system which is due to start. I'm not happy when I read another news report where our elderly pensioners are finding it increasing tougher to live and a reference to ghettos springing up across Australia. We have seen this paper publish a few stories re housing affordability along the Sunshine Coast, problems with people seeking access to the private rental market, others with rental costs etc.
I have held the view for at least 8 years now where Australia is clearly at a cross-road. I want our politicians to listen to our needs but when it comes to being part of a party machine, they remain silent and not many speak out against the party position.
I note the reference to the GST and this is one area where the Federal Treasurer has to include as part of the review into Australia's taxation system. The Queensland government encourages people to migrate to this state and yet, barriers continue to be in place because of the hunger for more and more money from taxpayers. As we draw closer to the State Treasurer handing down his first Budget and also noting the strong possibility of a Black Hole, the government won't back down on this cost.
on 22 May, 2008 at 10:35 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
I’m surprised you can defend Anna Bligh’s new tax on housing. I've talked to people in the industry, including subbies and they know that paying another $3500 per new home in extra tax doesn’t help them or other mums and dads purchasing these homes who are struggling with housing affordability. It’s another weasel tax to add to the cost of living on top of water and electricity hikes. I won’t stay silent as Queenslanders deserve better government management. I refer you to my press release of April 16 (Fionasimpson.com.au) and the Parliamentary record on this debate.
on 22 May, 2008 at 11:45 a.m. ( Suggest removal )
Most subbies I know would factor costs such as superannuation, insurances, etc into the hourly rate they charge the builder (if they dont they need to ask themselves why not). Given the new law would requrie builders to pay the super, workcover, etc then subbies could reduce their rates to take these amounts out. No-one loses out. Subbies still get the same amount, builders still pay the same amount. In a perfect world this is what would happen. Unfortunately greedy builders will insist that their costs are rising and therefore pass on a price increase to us the consumer. I hope the ACCC are watching.
on 22 May, 2008 at 1:03 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Fiona, it doesn't take a degree in economics to know that extra costs make houses more expensive.
Most of these blogs have not so much defended the new fees but have expressed support for the removal of the tax rort.

Can you please explain why the National Party believes this group of pseudo-subbies should be expected to carry the burden of 'housing affordability'?

Work Choices Mach II, perhaps?
on 22 May, 2008 at 3:10 p.m. ( Suggest removal )
Would it be fair to say that if the subbies and employees in the building industry are paid decent wages and conditions, our average income statistics might go up and we would no longer be rated as the least affordable place in Australia by the Housing Affordability indices ?

Before anyone jumps down my throat, I know that this doesn't actually make our homes more affordable - except for those subbies and employees who are earning more - but it would fix our Housing Affordability rating.

Have your say

We welcome comments on our stories and blogs - after all it's your site. Please note comments should be on-topic and not abusive. Comments are checked before publication.